The monapinone coupling enzyme (MCE), a fungal multicopper oxidase, catalyzes the regioselective C–C coupling between tricyclic monapinone A (the primary substrate) and other monapinones (secondary substrates) to produce atropisomeric biaryl homo- or heterodimers. In this study, mono-, bi- and tricyclic compounds were tested to determine whether they worked as secondary substrates for MCE. Among 14 cyclic compounds, MCE utilized semivioxanthin, YWA1, 1,3-naphthalenediol and flaviolin as secondary substrates to produce non-natural heterodimers. The atropisomeric biaryl heterodimers produced by MCE from monapinone A and semivioxanthin were isolated, and their structures were elucidated by NMR and MS. These findings indicate that MCE recognizes bi- and tricyclic compounds with a 1,3-dihydroxy or 1-hydroxy-3-methoxy benzene ring as a secondary substrate.