The Mo nitrogenase catalyzes the ambient reduction of N2 to NH3 at its M-cluster site. A complex metallocofactor with a core composition of [MoFe7 S9 C], the M-cluster, can be extracted from the protein scaffold and used to facilitate the catalytic reduction of CN- , CO, and CO2 into hydrocarbons in the isolated state. Herein, we report the synthesis, structure, and reactivity of an asymmetric M-cluster analogue with a core composition of [MoFe5 S9 ]. This analogue, referred to as the Mo-cluster, is the first synthetic example of an M-cluster mimic with Fe and Mo positioned at opposite ends of the cluster. Moreover, the ability of the Mo-cluster to reduce C1 substrates to hydrocarbons suggests the feasibility of developing nitrogenase-based biomimetic approaches to recycle C1  waste into fuel products.